Outside Online
advertisement
  • Home
  • Travel
  • Gear
  • Bodywork
  • Culture
  • Blog
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
  • Photos
  • Archives
  • Subscribe
Subscribe to Outside Magazine


You Are Here:   Home  >>   Travel   >>  See Mo' Evil

Adventure Adviser

Today's Question
What do you suggest for a cheap winter trip to Baja, Mexico? answer

Where in the United States can I stay overnight in a tree? answer

Can you suggest a great African safari? answer

Travel Resources
  • Best Trips 2008
  • Best Trips 2007
  • Best Trips 2006
  • Best Trips 2005
  • Best Trips 2004
  • Best Towns 2008
  • Best Towns 2007
  • Best Towns 2006
  • Best Towns 2005
  • Best Towns 2004
  • Plan Your Trip
  • Adventure Lodges
Travel Guides
  • The World
  • The United States
  • Canada
  • Caribbean
  • Mexico
  • Central America
  • South America
  • Europe
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Australia & South Pacific

Online Favorites

  • "Into Thin Air"
  • Best Adventure Books
  • The O Files: Unsolved Mysteries
  • Dream Towns
  • Dream Jobs

Special Issues

  • Family Road Trips
  • Interactive Colorado
  • Literary All-Stars
  • Adventure Lodges
  • Oceanic Endeavors
  • Adventure Goddesses

Photo Galleries

  • Malia Jones
  • Amanda Beard
  • Julia Mancuso
  • Women Who Rock
  • Kelly Slater
  • Olympic Cities
  • Exposure: Sara Carlson
  • See All Galleries
share this article del.icio.us DIGG Facebook StumbleUpon

Outside Magazine, April 2008

The Big Idea
See Mo' Evil
A traveler's best response to an oppressive regime? Go check it out.

By Stephanie Pearson


Shew Dragon Pagoda
BEYOND THE HEADLINES: Myanmar’s Shew Dagaon Pagoda (Corbis)

Normally, I wouldn't pick a fight with the world's only incarcerated Nobel Peace Prize winner, but I think Myanmar's Aung San Suu Kyi should stop urging tourists to avoid her country, which she does to prevent money from flowing to the despots who run it.

What do you think?
Share Your Opinion. Is it immoral to travel to a human-rights-violating country with an oppressive regime?

There's no denying that Myanmar (formerly Burma) is in bad hands: Suu Kyi has been under house arrest in Rangoon on and off since 1989. In 1990, her national election victory was ignored by the military-backed State Peace and Development Council. Meanwhile, General Than Shwe's brutal junta has destroyed 3,000 villages, displaced 1.5 million refugees, and conscripted 70,000 child soldiers. Still, Suu Kyi's call for an ongoing travel boycott seems misguided. It isn't depriving the SPDC of vital foreign cash, like she claims. It's depriving her democratic movement of potential supporters all over the globe.

Travel boycotts have long been used to deny funds and legitimacy to oppressive regimes, from apart­heid-era South Africa to Castro's Cuba. On paper, economic boycotts make sense, but their effect is outweighed by the benefits of having travelers take a look for themselves. Whether the setting is Myanmar or Tibet, the best way to combat oppression is to become an eyewitness. Once you've done that, it's impossible not to share what you've seen.

I learned this in 1984, when my dad, a Lutheran minister, returned from Nicaragua, where he'd been monitoring the situation between the U.S.-backed contras and the socialist Sandinista government. My adolescent brain couldn't grasp the complicated dynamics of a civil war. But I could understand the terrifying moment when he put his head in his hands and sobbed as he told me how he'd seen entire campesino families crammed into five-by-seven-foot cubicles, their homes while working on multinational banana plantations. The politics of that situation are different from what's happening in Myanmar, but the suffering isn't. A year after his trip, my dad visited churches around Minnesota and gathered a dozen people to return with him to Latin America.

This lesson about the transformative power of travel has stayed with me as I've journeyed through Colombia, Cuba, Guatemala, Venezuela, Bhutan, and other troubled places. Along the way I've made contributions where I thought they'd make a difference. When I go to Myanmar, that means watching very closely where my money goes.

Suu Kyi has argued that my visa fees would give the government hard currency, and that the hotels where I'd stay are owned by corrupt officials. She's right about who's getting most of the money, but she's overlooking the relative amounts involved. Last year, 248,000 tourists spent roughly $150 million in Myanmar. That's equivalent to roughly half of the country's gem trade, which a Human Rights Watch report placed at $297 million last year. And it's nothing compared with the $2.2 billion the regime earned in 2006 on natural-gas deals with neighboring Thailand, which run counter to American and European Union isolation policies.

With Myanmar's government focused on big-money resource deals, it's putting less energy into skimming tourist cash from its citizens. John Sugnet, vice president of sales and marketing for San Francisco-based Geographic Expeditions, says that according to his sources inside the country, 80 percent of the money his clients spend in Myanmar now goes to local people. At the same time, it's becoming easier to exchange dollars, which means tourists don't always have to use highly inflated and regulated currency certificates.

But visiting the world's dictatorships isn't just about money. It's about seeing-something boycott backers claim won't happen even if you do go. "The problem is that people who travel only in the golden triangle of Rangoon, Mandalay, and Inle Lake come out and say, 'It doesn't seem so bad,'" says Jeremy Woodrum, director of the nonprofit U.S. Campaign for Burma. "The regime restrains people from seeing the reality."

There are two problems with that argument. First, if Americans had been in Rangoon last September, the reality would have been clear. Government soldiers killed 31 protesters-most of them pacifist Buddhist monks-who were marching against a fuel-price hike. The SPDC shut down the country's Internet access during the violence, drastically limiting news reports. That level of secrecy isn't possible with a thriving tourism industry. And those tourists don't stay quiet once they get home. Second, smart travelers go beyond the government-fabricated facade. Take, for example, Hal Nathan, president of the Foundation for the People of Burma. After his first visit to Myanmar, in 1995, the former economist set up his California-based nonprofit. Twenty-one trips later, Nathan has coached hundreds of travelers on how to see the country responsibly.

"There's a good way and a not-so-good way to travel to Burma," says Nathan. "The best way is to become educated before you go, reach out to people once you're there, and never, ever do anything political."

Nathan is right. The only thing worse than allowing money to go to an evil regime is allowing an evil regime to exploit its citizens behind a veil of obscurity.




• Subscribe to Outside and get a FREE Gift!

• Give the gift of Outside Magazine!

• Subscribe to Outside Online's free weekly e-mail newsletter featuring gear reviews, fitness advice, galleries, podcasts, and more.
Find Rates
find flightsfind hotelsfind cars
From City name or airport code
To City name or airport code
Leave
calendar
Return
calendar
Find Rates

A new window will open for each site. Please disable popup blockers.
OrbitzTravelocity
ExpediaCheapTickets
HotwireKayak
SidestepPriceline
CostJet

Where City name or airport code
Check in
calendar
Check out
calendar
Guests


Rooms
Find Rates

A new window will open for each site. Please disable popup blockers.
OrbitzHotels.com
TravelocityExpedia
CheapTicketsHotwire
KayakSidestep
Priceline
Pick-up City
airport code
Pick-up date
calendar
Time
Drop-off City
airport code
Drop-off date
calendar
Time
Find Rates

A new window will open for each site. Please disable popup blockers.
orbitz.comcheaptickets.com
hotwire.compriceline.com
search

advertisement




Subscribe to Outside Magazine!

advertisement
Crocs Inspiring Soles

special featrues

Gear Spotlight: Adventure Electronics
Our esteemed Gear Guy hones in the FAQs of the digital world in this exclusive archive.
The Green Issue
Earth Day may fall in April, but global awareness should be a 365-day concern. Let us help you stay focused.





Vacation Packages

More Travel Deals
  • Save 50% on packages to thousands of destinations
  • Thanksgiving flights from $166
  • Last Minute Deals for travel this weekend or next
  • Ski destinations packages from $181
Sign up for our Travel Deals Newsletter


More From Outside Online

Outside August 2008

  • Best Towns
  • Jeff Lowe
  • Burma Cyclone
  • Triathlon Training

Special Issues

  • 2008 Summer Buyer's Guide
  • 2008 Winter Buyer's Guide
  • Outside Blog
  • Unsolved Mysteries

Outside July 2008

  • Andy Roddick
  • Fitness Special
  • Summer Road Trips
  • Canadian Adventures

Online Exclusives

  • Spooky Spots and Terrible Tales
  • Literary All-Stars
  • Oceanic Endeavors
  • Adventure Goddesses

Outside June 2008

  • Malia Jones
  • Weekend Escapes
  • Satellite Radio
  • Joe Papp

Online Favorites

  • Outside Gear Blog
  • Gear Guy
  • Fitness Q&A
  • Adventure Adviser

Outside May 2008

  • Anderson Cooper
  • Best Jobs 2008
  • Surf Genius
  • Russell Brice

Outside Classics

  • Into Thin Air
  • The Whale Hunters
  • Raising the Dead
  • The Long Way Home


Vacation Ideas from The Away Network

Outside's Best Towns 2008

  • Crested Butte, CO
  • New Orleans, LA
  • Portsmouth, NH
  • Washington, DC
  • Rest of the Best

Gay-Friendly Vacation Guides

  • Asia
  • Europe
  • South America
  • United States
  • All Vacation Destinations

Best Fall Foliage

  • Black Hills National Forest
  • Glacier National Park
  • Great Smoky Mountains
  • Monongahela National Forest
  • Shenandoah National Park

Trip-Planning Tools

  • Cheap Flights 101
  • Cheap Hotels 101
  • Compare Rates
  • Travel Insurance Tips
  • Vacation Rentals Index

Top Scenic Drives

  • California's Deserts
  • Mountain Tours
  • Upstate New York
  • Weekend Road Trips
  • See All Drives

GORP's Fall Outdoor Guides

  • Where to Camp
  • Where to Fish
  • Where to Hike
  • Where to Mountain Bike
  • All Fall Guides

GORPTravel Trips

  • Active Resorts
  • Horses & Riding
  • Nature Observation
  • Culinary Tours
  • Volunteer Vacations

Fall Travel Guides

  • Active Travel
  • Cultural Travel
  • Outdoor Travel
  • Romantic Travel
  • All Monthly Travel Guides



  • Home |
  • Travel |
  • Gear |
  • Bodywork |
  • Culture |
  • Videos |
  • Podcasts |
  • Photos |
  • Archives |
  • Feedback |
  • RSS Feeds |
  • Subscribe to Outside Magazine |
  • Join/Login




  • About Outside |
  • Advertise |
  • Terms of Use |
  • Subscription Services |
  • Sponsorship Policy |
  • Outside Info |
  • Site Map |
  • Press Room

  • Outside Magazine Media Kit |
  • Photo Department |
  • Privacy Policy |
  • Contact Us |
  • Contributor's Guidelines

Partner Sites:
  • Away.com |
  • GORP.com |
  • Orbitz |
  • Cheaptickets |
  • ebookers |
  • HotelClub.com |
  • RatesToGo.com |
  • asia-hotels.com |
  • Outside's Go


©1994-2008 Mariah Media Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction of material from any pages without written permission is strictly prohibited.